There's nothing quite like the comfort of warm, gooey cookies when those late-night cravings kick in. Along with Crumbl cookies, Insomnia cookies managed to solve these midnight yearnings with the promise of their admittedly pricey cookie lineup. But what can you do if there's no Insomnia location near you?
Perfect for keeping premade in the freezer, I've gathered over a half dozen irresistible copycat Insomnia cookies recipes that'll have you reaching for your apron (or just your toaster oven). For those who want the same flavor without the hassle - or pricetag - these Insomnia cookie copycat recipes recreate those delectable treats in the comfort of your own kitchen.
Jump to:
🌱 Vegan Insomnia Chocolate Chunk Cookie Recipe
While this may seem like yet another chocolate chunk recipe, I've switched it up by sharing a vegan Insmonia-style chocolate chunk. This recipe captures the essence of Insomnia's classic, delivering a perfect blend of crispy edges and a chewy, soft center with a vegan egg substitute and vegan butter.
To keep everything plant-based, vegan chocolate chunks are folded into the batter; but if you don’t have this on hand, feel free to substitute the chocolate for any type of chocolate that you have in your pantry.
☘️ Double Mint Chocolate Cookies
These double mint chocolate cookies are exactly what mint chocolate lovers dream about. This Insomnia Cookie-styled recipe is delectably soft and chewy and perfectly chocolatey and minty at the same time.
The cookies boast of melty milk chocolate & minty green chips, though you can swap as needed, doubling the cool mint flavor with Andes mints and mint Oreo pieces. The unique texture is both equally fudgy and refreshing, perfect for late-night snacking. You could also swap the chips for Keto chocolates, dairy-free chocolates, sugar-free chocolate chips, or some good old craft chocolate.
🍫 Copycat Insomnia S'mores Cookies
Another classic you can use to douse any late night cravings is found in these scrumptious campfire goodies. These Insomnia Cookies copycat recipe are all about the nostalgia of camp and summertime bonfires.
Featuring a deluxe blend of graham crackers, marshmallows, and dark chocolate, this recipe creates a cookie that's equal parts crunchy and gooey. This little copycat is all about capturing the texture and flavor of the original recipe, but using a combination of boxed brownie mix and pudding mix.
🍪 Classic with M&M’s
What's a better combination than everyone's favorite chocolate snack + fresh-baked cookies? This classic Insomnia cookies with M&M's is a recipe you'll want to save for a rainy day.
Colorful, fun, and utterly delightful, these are the best M&M cookies you'll have without actually going to Insomnia Cookies. They're soft and chewy with crisp edges and a candy-coated shell that'll melt in your mouth. They’re deliciously aesthetic perfect for an Easter, Spring or Mother’s day soiree.
🥜 Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Reese's have such a die-hard following that most bakeries and confectioneries have a Reese's-flavored or -inspired sweet treat on its menu. This Insomnia cookie copycat recipe is no exception.
Though the concept isn't new, like combining salt in chocolate, these copycat cookies are a pleasant revelation. The combination of creamy peanut butter and delicious chocolate flavor in every bite of these huge cookies are amazing. A heavenly mix of smoothness and crunch, this sweet and salty combo is a win in my book.
🥐 Cinnamon Roll Cookies
These cookies aren't just for a late-night treat. To prove their cookie-making prowess, Insomnia Cookies launched their sweet breakfast cookies lineup, including this deluxe cinnamon roll cookie. Like its breakfast cousins, cinnamon sticky buns or cinnamon rolls, these cookies are all about cinnamon sugar goodness with a thick dough but soft center.
However this hack is that and more; with its unique crispy crackling exterior, it makes for comforting late-night munchies. The creamy, buttery brown sugar cinnamon filling is so good you'll want to eat more than one or two cookies at a time. They’re excellent for breakfast, paired with healthy hot beverages like olive oil coffee or cacao tea.
🍫 Insomnia Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Yes, these cookies taste as good as they sound! These cookies take the classic chocolate chip cookie up a notch with an extra dose of chocolate with cocoa powder plus milk chocolate chunks.
They're chewy and incredibly chocolaty, with wonderfully crisp buttery edges, filled with milk chocolate chunks (from chopping up a chocolate bar) in true Insomnia Cookies fashion. You can add more cacao goodness in there by using an extra quarter cup of raw chocolate chunks or cacao nibs.
🙋 Frequently Asked Questions
Insomnia Cookies is a bakery chain that specializes in delivering warm cookies, brownies, and other sweet treats until late at night (like 2am). The company is known for its wide range of cookie flavors and its convenient delivery service, as well as its many college campus locations, making it a popular choice for late-night cravings.
Insomnia Cookies is known for its late-night delivery service, offering warm cookies, brownies, and other sweet treats until the wee hours of the morning. The company's variety of flavors and the convenience of having freshly baked goods delivered late at night make it a popular choice for indulging.
Insomnia Cookies' pricing can vary depending on the location and other factors. But the cost of their products may be influenced by the quality of ingredients used, the convenience of late-night delivery, and the overall experience of enjoying freshly baked treats.
Some of the most popular Insomnia Cookies flavors include Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, Double Chocolate Chunk, and M&M. These classic flavors are long-lasting and beloved for their delicious taste, often considered the brand's bestsellers.
Insomnia Cookies are known for their soft, chewy texture, often with a slightly crispy edge. This texture is a result of their freshly baked and warm nature, which adds to the overall indulgence of enjoying these treats.
📖 Recipe
7 Copycat Insomnia Cookies Recipes
Equipment
- Whisk
- Spatula
- Mixing Bowl
- Electric Mixer
Ingredients
Instructions
- Choose a recipe that appeals to you.
- Gather the ingredients.
- Follow the instructions, then enjoy!
Comments
No Comments