13 Copycat Crumbl Cookies Recipes to Make at Home 

These copycat Crumbl Cookies are the epitome of comfort food, with the perfect blend of softness and gooey chocolate chips melting in your mouth. This recipe even uses salted butter to balance out the sweetness of milk chocolate chips (much like Crumbl's classic cookie). 

To top it all off, this cookie has Crumbl's iconic humongous size with large milk chocolate chips (I recommend Guittard brand). It's the perfect blend of softness and gooey chocolate chips that melt in your mouth. 

But you can make this cookie any way you want. If you don’t have chocolate chips on hand, swap it out for any chocolate chip substitute that you have in your pantry. For a healthier version with less sugar, opt for sugar-free chocolate chips, but just ensure they’re larger than minis. 

You can bring the campfire life right back to your kitchen with these copycat Crumble s'mores cookies. Combine graham cracker crumbs, good quality chocolate or any type of chocolate you prefer or have on hand (even ruby chocolate), and a single pillowy marshmallow top for a gooey, nostalgic treat that'll bring you back to those evenings by the fire. 

The trick is to get the marshmallows beautifully roasted with a drizzle of white chocolate at the end.  

Crumbl's Reese's PB Cup Cookies are just a dream come true for peanut butter and chocolate lovers. This childhood lunch-flavored treat is common in Crumbl's weekly cookie rotation, and as well-loved as a chocolate or vanilla cookie.

These Crumbl copycat cookies feature the perfect fusion of creamy peanut butter and chopped chocolate peanut butter cups for double the flavor punch. They're also soft but crispy around the edges, topped with melted peanut butter, and finally garnished with more peanut butter cups. It’s chocolate peanut heaven!

These muddy buddy cookies take the OG muddy buddy snack and triple its deliciousness. In the original, Crumbl uses its signature soft and chewy peanut butter cookie and tops it with melted chocolate, Muddy Buddies (the OGs from Chex Mix), and a dusting of powdered sugar.

This copycat recipe serves up just that with the same irresistible and perfect combination of soft cookie, crunchy topping, and the beautiful marriage of peanut butter and rich chocolatey flavor.

This delicious caramel popcorn cookie recipe strikes a beautiful balance between sweetness and crunch. They offer a soft and chewy cookie base with thick caramel frosting and sticky caramel popcorn on top. But this particulr pick includes a unique twist that differs from Crumbl's recipe. 

Here they swap the frosting with a velvety cream cheese frosting while keeping that soft and chewy buttery cookie with caramel popcorn and caramel sauce on top.   

These copycat Crumbl chocolate oreo cookies bring the chocolate snack flavor to new life in cookie form. Loaded with a vanilla cream cheese frosting, oreo crumbs, and a healthy dark chocolate cookie base, this is the king of Crumbl cookie's most desirable cookies list. 

This recipe provides a delightful texture and flavor combination, much like the original cookies, with a rich and decadent chocolate cookie base and vanilla frosting. Oreo cookie snacking just got upgraded by this familiar combination of flavors and textures in a Crumbl-like fashion.   

"Incredible on so many levels," said one Instagrammer and so many others about Crumbl's Churro cookies. Feeling left out? Well, you don't have to if you make this carnival favorite from Crumbl's ever-changing cookie lineup. These churro cookies are warm, crisp cookies dusted with cinnamon sugar and topped with cinnamon buttercream frosting.

They'll transport your taste buds to cookie nirvana with a crispy, cinnamon-sugar coating and a soft, warm center. There's just nothing ordinary about these copycat cinnamon cookies, as they'll have you dunking them in thick, drinking chocolate just as the Spanish do. Great alternatives would be a homemade gianduja or dark chocolate sauce. 

In dire need of a gluten-free version of Crumbl's snickerdoodle cupcake cookie? This recipe is the answer. It's the same cinnamon-sugar delight with a perfectly crispy exterior and a soft, chewy interior, only it's made with gluten-free ingredients. 

This just means swapping out the regular flour for a gluten-free alternative blend. And while the cinnamon buttercream frosting is different from Crumbl's cream cheese frosting, it's just as good as the original. I love this with my favorite cup of joe or a freshly brewed cup of cacao tea. 

Our lives are much simpler when working with a box cake mix. So, if we must include one on our list, it'll have to be a hack to Crumbl's confetti cake cookies. True to Crumbl form, these copycat cookies are whimsical, fun, and aesthetic, providing a sensory experience that's as visually appealing as it is tasty. 

Cake batter cookies with cake mix, cream cheese frosting, and rainbow sprinkles - what more can your heart desire? You can easily replicate the recipe with an instant mix, cream cheese frosting, and colorful sprinkles.  

Yup, the recipe title says all that, and promises even more. This Crumbl German chocolate cake cookie dupe offers the same chocolate-coconut-caramel indulgence as the original. 

It brings to the table the dense and fudgy texture of an ultra-moist chocolate cake with a rich cocoa flavor that's perfect for chocoholics. You also get a splash of caramel, coconut, and pecans for an all-around sweetness. 

Get ready to embark on a cookie-making adventure that'll satisfy your cravings for a carrot cake and allow you to bring home the magic of Crumbl cookies all in one go. This Easter bunny-approved cookie recipe has the earthy notes of carrot with just the right amount of sweetness and hints of spice, all topped with a decadent cream cheese frosting. 

It's a warm, gooey, and oversized cookie that aims to satisfy your carrot cake cravings. It’s a perfect Springtime dessert or Easter dessert.   

These lemon bar Crumbl copycat cookies are like a zesty and sweet burst of sunshine. They feature a rich, decadent, tangy lemon topping that perfectly complements the soft buttery cookie base. 

Do you feel like amping up the tartness of the OG cookie even more? You can make your own lemon curd and increase the tang in the cookie recipe to make it the best version of itself for your taste buds. With any leftover lemon curd, try any of the tangy treats of all these lemon curd desserts.

This Crumbl key lime pie copycat cookie does the original justice as it's truly bursting with flavor - citrusy, sweet, and tart all at the same time. It combines everything delicious about key lime pie into one glorious cookie, and I can't get enough of it.

The cookie is served on a thin graham cracker pie crust cookie base, piped with a zesty, velvety key lime cream cheese frosting. Finally it's topped with whipped cream, graham crumbs, and a slice of fresh lime just for good measure. They're the epitome of sweet tangy lime desserts, though they're more yellow desserts than bright green ones.