Skip to Content

11 Best Cocoa Powder Substitutes (Chocolate Expert’s Picks)

Sharing is caring!

People love baking with cocoa powder. It adds a deep chocolatey flavor to your favorite desserts, and a silky texture to hot or cold beverages. Rich, smooth, and delectably delicious, cocoa powder elevates any homemade dessert to a divine and indulgent treat.

My first two (and overall the easiest) recommended cocoa powder substitutes are dutch-processed cocoa and cacao powder, if you already have them on hand. This is because cocoa powder, cacao powder, baking cocoa, and dutch cocoa are all the same thing

Dutch-processing flattens the chocolate flavor, but they’re all made by pressing & removing fat from cacao beans, then grinding the leftover solids into a fine powder. But what do you do when you’ve completely run out of this much-used baking ingredient? 

You won’t need to go for a chocolate grocery run with these cacao powder substitutes! Simply rummage in your pantry for baking chocolate, chocolate chips, a dark chocolate bar, or even an instant hot cocoa, and get ready to make your favorite treat. 

What is Cocoa Powder?

The highly concentrated, unsweetened chocolate product, cocoa powder, also known as chocolate powder or cacao powder, is made from roasted and ground cocoa beans that have been fermented and roasted. 

Cocoa is thought to have been used heavily by the Mesoamerican peoples of Central America, and then introduced to Europe by the Spanish conquistadors in the 16th century. The beans are harvested and fermented, before being dried and then shipped to chocolate-making countries.

There they’re lightly roasted to develop their chocolatey flavor before removing the shells. Grinding the roasted cocoa nibs produces a paste known as cocoa liquor or chocolate liquor. When the liquid is pressed to remove roughly 75% of its cocoa butter, the remaining cocoa solids are processed to make cocoa powder.

Because cocoa powder is derived from the cocoa bean itself through the process above, it contains antioxidants as well as incredible nutritional value. Pure cocoa powder is also lower in calories, fat, and sugar than chocolate off the shelf. Opt for higher-quality cocoa powders if you’re looking to get the maximum health benefits out of your baked goods.

Cocoa powder is rich in the energy-boosting caffeine & theobromine, and is one of the best sources of polyphenols. These are antioxidants linked to a number of health advantages, such as greater blood flow, reduce inflammation, improved cholesterol, and blood sugar levels, improved cognitive function, and can protection from diseases such as cancer & diabetes.

It is particularly rich in flavanols, a type of polyphenol which has strong antioxidant properties and may lower your risk of heart attack and stroke. Some cocoa powders have almost all of the cocoa butter removed, resulting in a powder that is primarily made up of finely ground solids. Others retain more of their cocoa butter, yielding a richer and fattier product (some retain as much as 25%).

Higher-quality cocoa powder retains slightly more cocoa butter than regular brands. The average grocery store brand of cocoa powder contains primarily cocoa solids, with only about 10-15% residual fat. 

Types of Cocoa Powder

Cocoa powder can easily be found in the baking section of major grocery stores. There are typically a few to choose from, but at least in the US, all of them will be either dutch-processed or natural cocoa powders. The main difference between the two is in the way they are processed, which results in varying levels of acidity and pH between the types. Cocoa beans are naturally acidic, with a pH level between 5 and 6.2.

Dutch-processed cocoa or alkalized cocoa powder has been treated with an alkaline solution to neutralize the acidity of the cocoa, raising the pH to between 6.8 and 8.1. To lessen the inherent acidity of lower-quality cacao beans, cocoa powder is frequently alkalized (or dutch-processed) during processing.

The result is a powder that’s darker in color and tastes flatter but less bitter (the latter of which isn’t a problem with high-quality cacaos). This type of cocoa powder also dissolves more easily, making it easier to work into recipes like ice cream and beverages.

Natural cocoa powder, on the other hand, is not chemically treated with alkali, which leaves it’s naturally lighter color and acidic pH. Also called natural unsweetened cocoa powder or simply cocoa not processed with alkali, this powder tends to offer brighter, fruitier flavors. It works best in recipes that also call for baking soda, because the acidity helps to activate leavening agents (like baking soda) in recipes.

How to Use Cocoa Powder

While known for its role in hot cocoa and mole sauce, cocoa powder is most popular as an important baking ingredient. Any recipe that calls for chocolate calls for smooth, intense flavors only offered by the richness of cocoa powder. 

The outcome of your baked goods may vary depending on the variety of cocoa powder you use. Most recipes call for either dutch-processed cocoa powder or natural unsweetened cocoa powder.

Dutch-processed cocoa powder offers a dark color and intense chocolate taste to recipes. Natural cocoa powder’s higher acidity lends a slightly fruitier and more dynamic flavor. It also means that if the recipe calls for baking soda, to avoid an overly leavened cake, you may want to slightly decrease the amount of leavening agent.

Baking chocolate cakes or any style of cake with cocoa powder makes it taste extra chocolatey and cakey. This is because most of the cocoa butter is removed from cocoa powder, and with the lack of fat, it makes for lighter sponge cakes while still adding that rich chocolatey flavor! 

Adding the cocoa powder directly to your dry ingredients in a recipe will improve the structure and texture of your baked goods. You can also use it for brownies, bundts, cupcakes, and as a surprisingly pleasant twist in savory recipes.

Cocoa powder also offers itself as a substitute for dark chocolate or baking chocolate in many recipes. Here are some amazing recipes with cocoa powder:

Best Cocoa Powder Substitutes (9 More!)

We know that there is a difference between natural and dutch-processed cocoa powders. They can be used interchangeably in most recipes, but when baking, you may need to tweak the leavening. When you don’t have any, go for one of these easy cocoa powder alternatives listed below.

You may even have some of these in your pantry already, and can skip the trip to the store altogether. However, keep in mind that you may not achieve the same texture or flavor with some of these, so read carefully. As always, do your best to determine which would work best to replicate the flavors and textures needed.

Baking Chocolate (Unsweetened Chocolate)

Baking chocolate or unsweetened chocolate is 100% chocolate liquor. Known by a bevy of names, including— but not limited to— cacao liquor, cacao mass, tableya, cocoa liquor, cocoa mass, and even just “chocolate.”

But whatever you call it, this liquid is made from cacao beans (also called cocoa beans or cocoa nibs), and it contains both cocoa solids & cocoa butter in roughly equal measure. Unsweetened chocolate is generally used in baking as well as to make desserts.

With its higher percentage of cocoa solids, baking chocolate offers itself as the best and simplest substitute for cacao powder. The flavor can be quite bitter when made with lower-quality cacao, and it can still be used to achieve a dark & richer color in baked goods and desserts. 

Use four tablespoons of unsweetened baking chocolate for every three tablespoons of cocoa powder called for in a recipe. To make the swap, before adding the chocolate to your wet ingredients, melt it until fully liquid. Additionally, because chocolate contains more fat than cocoa powder, reduce the amount of fat used in your recipe by a tablespoon per every four tablespoons of chocolate used.

Chocolate Chips

Baking chocolate may not be the best option if you want to add cocoa powder for a milder and sweeter flavor in your recipes. We look to chocolate chips as a replacement for cacao powder because they tend to be sweeter than baking chocolate, made up of up to half sugar. 

Chocolate chips are small round morsels or chunks of sweetened chocolate widely used in baking. They’re made by carefully refining cacao with sugar, lecithin, and sometimes milk, extra cocoa butter, and vanilla. If you’ve run out of cocoa powder, a simple substitute would be chocolate chips; the higher the cacao percentage, the better.

Just like with baking chocolate, the chocolate chips will have to be melted before being added to the recipe. Remember that chocolate chips contain less cocoa butter and stabilizers to help them maintain their “chip” shape while baking.

Semi-sweet or milk chocolate chips contain more sugar than bittersweet chocolate chips. If this is all you have on hand, you can compensate for this by reducing the amount of sugar or other sweeteners you add.

It’s also a good idea to slightly reduce the butter or shortening to compensate for any cocoa butter in the chocolate. Use 2-3 ounces of chocolate chips (depending on sugar content) as a swap for 1.5 ounces of cocoa powder, but just remember to compensate for the extra fat. 

Cacao Nibs

Cacao Nibs (Cocoa Nibs)

While less common than the above-mentioned cocoa powder alternatives, cacao nibs are the full-fat, les–processed version of cocoa powder. They’re the raw material from which cacao butter is pressed, and then cacao powder is made by grinding it into the fine dust we all know and love.

To substitute cacao powder with cacao nibs, they must be lightly baked in the oven for about 5 minutes at 200°F (95°C). Then add the warm nibs to a strong blender or food processor and grind them in 2-second pulses for about 1 minute.

The mixture will be very thick, like a cacao paste, and can be used in brownies, cakes, and frostings, though it won’t have the same texture. Swap this rough grind for cocoa powder in a 1-to-1 ratio.

Dark Chocolate Bar

One of the easiest-to-find replacements for cocoa powder is a dark chocolate bar. Dark chocolate has a higher cocoa content than other types, making it the closest in chocolate richness to cocoa powder.

Dark chocolate, like cocoa powder, is rich and often bitter, made from pure cocoa + sugar. It also has a lovely dark color that will keep your chocolate desserts look stunning. Check for higher cocoa percentages printed on the front label of your dark chocolate bar.

A higher cocoa percentage indicates a higher ratio of cacao to sugar, and a higher proportion of cocoa solids. The higher the percentage, the more comparable it will be to cocoa powder. If your recipe relies on the bitterness of cocoa powder, dark chocolate is an excellent alternative.

To use dark chocolate candy bars, melt the chocolate and measure out four tablespoons of liquid chocolate to replace three tablespoons of cocoa powder. Just remember to compensate for the extra fat; check the nutrition label on the back to figure it out.

Couverture (Melting Chocolate)

If you make candies or dipping chocolate, you may be familiar with couverture chocolate. Also known as simply ‘couverture,’ this type of chocolate contains more cocoa butter than other types. It’s most commonly found in the production of professional chocolate bars, barks, candy, brownies, and cakes, as the extra fat makes it easier to work with. 

Couverture chocolate contains a higher percentage of cocoa butter. This makes it extra smooth and creamy, making it perfect for dipping. While not an ideal substitute for cocoa powder, it will suffice in a pinch. The resulting creations will be sweeter, darker, and have a slightly different texture, as well as a prominent chocolate flavor.

It’s simple to swap couverture chocolate for cocoa powder. Simply melt the couverture and use the appropriate amount in your recipe. Once the chocolate has melted, substitute four tablespoons for every three tablespoons of cocoa powder called-for. Just remember to adjust the amount of fat in the recipeas couverture chocolate has even more fat than other types.

Drinking Chocolate 

Chocolate drinking powder, for the most part, will be mostly made up of chocolate in a rough grind. Commercial types are typically dutch-processed to be more soluble, and use higher-fat cacaos to produce a rich and flavorful mixture of chocolate, vanilla, and sugar.

Drinking chocolate powder makes for the best swap for cocoa powder when baking brownies, cakes, cookies, and other desserts. You can start at a one-to-one ratio, but since it contains sugar, you’ll likely want to reduce the amount of sugar you use in the recipe.

The sweetness of drinking chocolates varies greatly. A drinking chocolate mix with a higher cocoa percentage will typically be less sweet than one with a lower percentage, and would make for a better replacement for cacao powder.

If your drinking chocolate doesn’t say the percentage, check the packaging and nutritional information to see how much sugar was added per serving, then calculate from there. Remember that adding more sweetener to your recipe is always simple, so consider starting with less.

Carob Powder

When you run out of cocoa powder but still want to make a chocolate cake, you have several options, including a non-chocolate alternative like carob powder. Carob powder, also known as carob flour, is a common cocoa powder alternative.

Carob powder resembles cocoa powder, but is prepared from dried, roasted carob tree pods, which come from a tree native to the Mediterranean. The powder is available in both raw and roasted forms; the lightly-roasted powder has a sweeter flavor than the dark-roasted powder, which has a more bitter, intense flavor.

In baked goods, carob powder is frequently used as a natural sweetener. It’s distinctly earthy while also mildly bitter, sweet, and nutty. While carob powder has almost no fat, it has more sugar and carbohydrates than cocoa powder, but is similarly high in dietary fiber and antioxidant polyphenols.

When using carob powder to substitute for cocoa powder in baking, it needs to be in a recipe where you need a sweet chocolate flavor. Use it as a 1:1 replacement for cocoa powder; however, you may need to lessen the sweetener in your recipe to offset it. If you have extra, carob makes for an excellent addition to foods like pancakes, oatmeal, and milkshakes. 

Chocolate Spread (NOT Nutella)

While you can’t make this swap with nutella (its first 3 ingredients are sugar, palm oil, and hazelnuts!), any high-quality chocolate spread can be used as long as its first or second ingredient is cocoa powder. The other top ingredient should be a nut or sweetener of some kind.

This swap can be used in any batter, fudge, or frosting, but you’ll need to offset either the sugar or the sugar & nuts/oils added. Usually this means swapping chocolate spread for cocoa powder in a 2:1 or 3:1 ratio, checking the nutrition facts of your particular chocolate spread to see how much of it is sugar.

Hot Cocoa Mix (Hot Chocolate Mix)

A good quality hot cocoa mix can often substitute cocoa powder when you’re in a pinch. One wonderful thing about higher cocoa content products is their flexibility in allowing you to alter the taste by adding more sugar or milk if you find it too intense, but too much sugar is hard to take out.

Just as its name suggests, hot cocoa (or hot chocolate) has cocoa powder in it. However, it only has a small amount of cocoa powder and has many other ingredients like sugar, milk, and other additives.

Hot cocoa mix is chocolatey powder usually made with very little cocoa, more milk powder, sugar, and hydrogenated oils than the cocoa powder we’re swapping out. To get enough of the chocolate flavor (and it will likely not be a rich enough one), you need to use hot cocoa mix in a 2:1 substitution for cocoa powder.

You will be adding less cocoa powder to your recipe, as well as the addition of whatever else may be in the cocoa mix (like a ton of sugar), so start by adding half of what you need and adjusting form there.

Sharing is caring!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.